Best Restaurants to Get Gulf Coast Shrimp in Naples, FL

July 18th, 2022 by

Naples, Florida’s location on the Gulf Coast makes it one of the top places in the area for seafood. From the waterfront dining to downtown restaurants and seafood shacks, Naples has some of the best restaurants along the Paradise Coast, and many of them have gulf shrimp on the menu. Take a look at the top spots for gulf shrimp in the area.

Captain & Krewe Seafood Market & Raw Bar

Captain & Krewe is the place to go in Naples when you’re looking for delicious shrimp in a casual, laid-back atmosphere. The restaurant sits right off 5th Avenue South and has indoor and outdoor seating. It’s perfect when you’re out shopping in Naples and start craving some perfectly prepared gulf shrimp.

The menu features spicy Cajun shrimp on their small plate menu, and you can get them either hot or cold. Both are peel-and-eat and come seasoned with spicy Cajun seasoning. Also, the Manhattan shrimp chowder is always a great choice, even on a warm Florida day.

Island Gypsy Cafe

If you’re looking for the ultimate hidden gem in Naples, head to Island Gypsy Cafe. It’s on the Isle of Cari and has a nautical vibe. If you get there early enough, make sure to request a table outside on the deck where you can enjoy the beautiful views of the Gulf. Leave plenty of time to enjoy yourself at Island Gypsy Cafe.

If you start with the Gypsy Punch, you’ll get to enjoy a delicious drink with a combination of light rum, flavored brandy, and dark tropical schnapps mixed with fresh fruit juice. From there, choose from peel & eat shrimp with Kona Big Wave Beer boiled shrimp and cocktail sauce with Old Bay seasoning or the coconut shrimp with mango horseradish marmalade.

The PO-boy fried shrimp wrap is always a good choice for your meal. It’s made with flash-fried shrimp, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sweet Thai chili,  and coleslaw wrapped in a warm tortilla.

The Dock at Crayton Cove

You can’t go wrong at The Dock at Crayton Cove. This casual outdoor dining spot is a local favorite. The owners have been serving Naples’ residents and visitors since 1976, and if you stop by for dinner, start with the dock shrimp nachos. These come with jack cheese, green chili, Pico de Gallo, and sour cream. The coconut shrimp is also a top choice. This small plate has coconut fried shrimp served with tropical fruit, mint, and palm sugar sauce.

If you like your shrimp from the raw bar, you can get peel & eat shrimp or jumbo shrimp cocktail. But, if you want to try a little of everything, get the Captain’s seafood tower. It comes with all your favorites from the sea, including oysters, mussels, middleneck clams, tune poke, jumbo shrimp, and Maine lobster.

The Dock at Crayton Cove’s menu has something for everyone, and you can get your seafood and gulf shrimp any way you like. Choose fried, grilled, or blackened, and enjoy it with rice and beans, mashed potatoes, or sauteed green beans.

Swan River Seafood Restaurant & Fish Market

At  Swan River Seafood Restaurant & Fish Market, you can buy your fresh seafood to take home or enjoy it at the restaurant. Stop by for lunch and start with the shrimp and scallop Caprese with pesto seared shrimp and scallop with basil, spinach, fresh mozzarella, vine-ripe tomatoes, Italian dressing, and balsamic glaze.

The dinner menu has several gulf shrimp options starting with the steamed peel-and-eat shrimp or the beer’n bay shrimp. The broiled seafood platter is one of the Swan Signatures and comes with gulf shrimp, sea scallops, cod, white wine, butter, and lemon-herb seasoning. The menu also features seafood pasta dishes and surf and turf. You can get a filet mignon with garlic shrimp topped with a mushroom demi-glaze.

You’ll find Swan River Seafood Restaurant & Fish Market at 3741 Tamiami Trail North in Naples.

Mr. Big Fish Seafood & Bar

Mr. Big Fish Seafood & Bar is not only one of Naples’ hidden gems; it’s one of the best seafood restaurants in the area. Tucked away in a strip mall off Route 41, this restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere where you can sit and enjoy good food made with fresh ingredients.

The menu features a wide variety of seafood, including gulf shrimp, prepared in several different ways. The shrimp cargo starter has shrimp baked in white wine and garlic butter, and it’s topped with bread crumbs and served with parmesan toast points. If you prefer cold shrimp, try the shrimp cocktail.

One of the chef’s favorites is the shrimp scampi. This traditional dish has garlic, butter, lemon, and white wine, and it’s served with pasta and gulf shrimp. The shrimp Oscar is also a good choice. It comes with lump crab-crusted jumbo shrimp served with sauteed spinach, rice, and lemon butter.

Mr. Big Fish has a fantastic bar with some delicious house drinks. The ocean mojito has rum, pomegranate juice, fresh blueberries, lime, and mint. If you like key lime, make sure to get the key lime martini. It’s made with Stoli vanilla, pineapple juice, and key lime beach liqueur. It’s served in a martini glass with a graham cracker rim.

USS Nemo

USS Nemo was voted the best restaurant in Naples by local diners. This upscale seafood restaurant serves lunch and dinner daily, and it also has an extensive wine list, a kid’s menu, and delicious desserts.

The Nemo signature dish is the miso broiled sea bass, which comes with a citrus butter sauce, a choice of steamed rice or potato puree, and carrot and asparagus tempura. If you have your heart set on gulf shrimp, make sure to get the lobster and shrimp pappardelle pasta. This dish has fresh Maine lobster, bacon, gulf shrimp, corn, and a creamy tomato sauce infused with lobster. The Yuzo shrimp is also a great choice but be prepared for some extra spice.

These are some of our favorite spots for gulf shrimp in Naples. If you know of some other places we missed, stop by Bonita Springs Mitsubishi and tell us about them. You can check out our new and used inventory while you’re there and find an excellent ride to get you around Naples.

Posted in Local